[<Works>]">Middleton-St JohnsTreeMailigListIndexMain Page | About | FAQ | Log in
Find:   


Writings by Bayle St.John

Cleopatra's Needle

TO THE EDITOR OF THE TIMES.

Sir, --The project for the removal of Cleopatra’s Needle from Alexandria, announced in your number of 11th instant seems already to have suggested another act of spoliation. Some of your correspondents, while anxious to protect, the tomb of the kings and the Thebian temples, point to the colossal statue (which, they tell us, is of Rameses 11.) at Mitarahenny, and hint that it should be transferred to England.

This, statue, one of the most remarkable in Egypt, lies on its face in a hole, which is annually filled to the brim in inundation time. Two of your corespondents describe it as “partially covered with sand;” but they must have glanced at it askance when dashing along at fill speed on donkey-back towards the Sakkarah district. There is no sand at Mitrarahenny, which is situated at the centre of a rich plain of alluvial soil, amidst vast palm groves. Every one who has beheld it must have regretted its neglected condition, and blamed the meanness which has left it, though English property, exposed for many years to the chances of destruction. A pension of 5.ls. a year was formerly paid to an Arab dame who acted as guardian, but now this magnificent work is left under the care of a voluntary conservator. At very slight expense it might be placed erect for the gratification of travellers; but it would be better to leave it buried in the mud, water, sand, than bring it to England. 

We shall have no sooner given the signal of destruction by laying hands on it, than the whole world will proceed to Egypt armed with pickaxe, shovel and lever, perhaps with gunpowder, and the new Cambyses may come to Thebes and find nothing worth ruining. Since Dr Lepsius’s escapades there has been a pause in the work of dilapidation, and a good opportunity seems to have arrived for clearing out, enclosing, and protecting the ancient monuments of Egypt. Bu here we are at it again. We are going to begin with a work which is pronounced to be "not an act of Vandalism and desecration;" then we are to be lured on to Mitrahenny, just in sight of the tomb of Psamitichus, where Dr. Lepsius played those pranks that make all English tourists hold up their hands in horror; and then, with a fair breeze, we shall hoist sail for Thebes, where there is still plenty of room for vandalism, nor stop till we come to Abu Sambal. Let us remember, however, that if we take statues and columns, the French may have a fancy for wall-paintings and the Prussians for bas-reliefs, so that in a very few years Murray’s Handbook may be about as intelligible as Pausanias.

I am, sir, your obedient servant
BAYLE ST. JOHN

Nov 11  

        


Retrieved from "http://www.middleton-stjohns.com/wiki/Web:HS-Writings:Articles-Cleopatra%27s_Needle"

This page has been accessed 117 times. This page was last modified 22:27, 9 December 2009. Content is available under MediaWiki:Licenses.